Why The
Frugal Fatty?
A Word, A Statement, A Revolution.
For far too long, “fat” has been a word whispered like a secret, thrown like an insult, or cushioned with apologies. But here’s the truth: Fat is just a word. It’s not a bad word, a dirty word, or a word to be feared. It’s simply a descriptor—no different than tall, short, skinny, or curvy.
At The Frugal Fatty, we’re reclaiming “fat” and stripping it of the negative power society has attached to it. We refuse to let a simple adjective be used as a weapon. Instead, we wear it boldly, proudly, and without shame.
And here’s the reality: 67% of U.S. women are considered plus-size. We are not a niche—we are the majority. And yet, for decades, the fashion industry has treated us like an afterthought, offering limited options, inflated prices, and uninspired styles.
Enough.
When you walk into The Frugal Fatty, you’re stepping into a space where size is not a limitation but a celebration. Where fashion is about expression, not exclusion. Where we don’t tiptoe around the word “fat” because it’s not something to tiptoe around.
Fat is not a feeling. Fat is not an insult. Fat is just… fat.
And when we remove the stigma, we take back the power. We remind the world that every body—no matter its shape or size—deserves to look and feel amazing.
Forget what you’ve been told about plus-size fashion.
For decades, the industry has ignored us, overcharged us, and expected us to settle. We’re done with that.
At The Frugal Fatty, we believe that fashion is for every body, every budget, every occasion. Whether you're dressing for work, a first date, or a night out, we make sure you never have to settle for less.
This isn’t just a resale shop. This is a rebellion. A rebellion against overpriced, uninspired plus-size fashion. The fashion industry is robbing plus-size shoppers blind and The Frugal Fatty is here to help you fight! Every piece you find here is a small victory toward winning the war.
​
Welcome to a New World. Welcome to The Frugal Fatty.
Essential Picks
We've carefully curated a selection of wardrobe essentials that are versatile, comfortable, and effortlessly stylish.
Try on and buy today.
What Treasures You'll Find
We believe in the beauty of simplicity and the power of sophistication. Our brand is dedicated to providing elegant and comfortable fashion solutions for individuals of all sizes. Here are a few of the thousands of brands we carry.
FAQ
For the protection of the entire community, we request that you do not bring in your items if you believe you have flu-like symptoms or have come into contact with anyone infected by Coronavirus in the past 14 days.
We only accept cleaned and/or new with tags items
Bring in your new, unused and CLEAN gently used plus size and/or big & tall clothing items including special occasion, formal wear and couture custom gowns size 12 and up. All submissions should be in excellent condition, laundered, odor free, and immediately ready to resell and wear.
What we accept
​
-
Men’s sizes 38+ and women’s plus sizes 12+.
-
We accept almost all types of clothing as long as it is new or in gently used, good, clean condition with no rips, tears, missing buttons, broken zippers, etc.
-
Men’s and women's shoes, boots, and handbags that are gently used, unworn or new in box.
-
Men’s and women’s accessories including jewelry, belts, scarves, watches, sunglasses, and more.
We do not accept
​
-
Fast fashion such as Shein, Temu, Rainbow, etc. Slippers, lingerie, or underwear, apart from bras.
-
Any items not appropriately laundered, ripped, torn (except intentional distressing), and/or stained, missing buttons, damaged, or missing tags/labels.
-
All items not accepted for any reason will be returned to you or we can donate upon your request.
What we pay
​
Cash in Hand: We offer between 25% and 35% of what we price items at in cash. We pay a higher percentage for high-demand brands. We pay a little less for mass-produced brands.
Trade In
To maximize your payout, trade in with us! We pay 25% more than the cash value in trade. Store credit is valid for 12 months. With thousands of items to choose from, we think you’ll find sustainable styles you’ll love.
Consignment
For high-end brands such as Chanel®, Louis Vuitton, Prada, or specialty items, we offer cash and consignment. When you consign with us, we pay you up to 60% of the selling price when the item sells. We take care of the details, so you don’t have to manage a listing or deal with returns!